Our famous
Key Lime Pie
Before there was a store filled with Florida flavors, there was a single recipe, our authentic Key Lime Pie.
Perfected over time using real Key lime juice and a buttery graham cracker crust, it quickly became more than a dessert. It became the reason people gathered, celebrated, and shared a taste of Florida sunshine.
That recipe didn’t just win hearts — it inspired the creation of The Florida Key Lime Pie Company itself.
From our record-breaking 12-foot pie to every slice served today, this dessert is at the heart of our story and the soul of our shop.
By The Slice
On A Stick
Whole Pies
Three Ways To Enjoy Our Pie
At The Florida Key Lime Pie Company, there’s more than one way to enjoy Florida’s most iconic dessert. From the perfect slice, to our famous Key Lime Pie on a Stick dipped in rich chocolate, to whole pies ready to share with family and friends — each treat is crafted fresh with our signature recipe. However you choose to enjoy it, every bite is a true taste of Florida sunshine.
The Classic Slice
Our signature recipe served one slice at a time. Each piece is baked fresh with real Key lime juice, a golden graham cracker crust and love.
Perfect for savoring in-store or as a quick sweet stop after the beach.”
Pie on a Stick
Cocoa Beach’s most portable dessert! We take a slice of our famous Key Lime Pie, freeze it, dip it in rich chocolate, and serve it on a stick.
A refreshing treat to enjoy as you stroll the beach or explore the town.
For Every Occasion
Bring home the taste of Florida with a fresh frozen full pie. Perfect for family gatherings, cruise ship travelers, or anyone who wants to share.
Whole pies are available daily for pickup
Key Lime Pie
The Inspiration That Started It All
Before there was a store filled with Florida flavors, there was a single recipe, our authentic Key Lime Pie.
Perfected over time using real Key lime juice and a buttery graham cracker crust, it quickly became more than a dessert. It became the reason people gathered, celebrated, and shared a taste of Florida sunshine.
That recipe didn’t just win hearts — it inspired the creation of The Florida Key Lime Pie Company itself.
From our record-breaking 12-foot pie to every slice served today, this dessert is at the heart of our story and the soul of our shop.