Step Inside Our All-Florida Store
Taste, Sip, and Explore the Sweet Side of Cocoa Beach.
Cool Off & Indulge
From creamy Key Lime Pie Ice Cream to tropical twists like Mango Guava Cheesecake, every scoop is made to beat the Cocoa Beach heat. Grab a cone and taste the sunshine in every bite.
Crafted in the Sunshine State
Build your own six-pack from our rotating lineup of Florida craft and seasonal beers. Explore playful labels and local favorites—perfect for pairing with a slice of pie or taking back to the beach.
Our Local Celebrity
Meet Sweetie the Alligator—Cocoa Beach’s most famous reptile and our honorary store mascot! Snap a selfie, tag @flkeylimepieco, and join our wall of smiling visitors from around the world.
Turn Up the Heat
From mild mango to ghost-pepper inferno, our wall of 500+ sauces is a fiery adventure for every taste. Discover local Florida favorites, rare imports, and novelty bottles that make perfect souvenirs—or dares.
Sip & Savor the Sunshine
Discover sweet Florida fruit wines crafted from mango, key lime, pineapple, and passion fruit. Each bottle captures the vibrant flavor of the tropics—perfect to enjoy back home or as a thoughtful Florida gift.
A Bite of Beachside Nostalgia
Colorful, chewy, and full of Florida flavor—our hand-pulled salt water taffy is a Cocoa Beach classic. Mix and match your favorite flavors or grab a gift bag to bring a little seaside sweetness home.
How have I never known about the Florida Key Lime Pie Company?! 🍋💛
Y’all know I love LOCAL… and this place is packed with Florida-made goodies from all over the state. The homemade ice cream? So creamy and delicious — and honestly way more affordable than most beach spots. 🙌
It’s right across the street from the beach in Cocoa Beach, which makes it the perfect little stop after some sun. And the Key Lime pie… let’s just say next time I’m getting the whole thing instead of a slice because it disappeared way too fast. 😅
If you’re in Cocoa Beach, add this to your list. And if you’re there on a Saturday or Sunday, pop in and say hi to Sweetie… my alligator friend. 🐊💚
📍 102 Dixie Lane, Cocoa Beach
#FloridaKeyLimePieCompany
#CocoaBeach
#SupportLocalFL
#KeyLimePie
#FloridaEats
This might be the most Florida thing I’ve ever done. Yes, that’s an alligator. Yes, I’m giving her a pedicure. And yes… her name is Sweetie 😅🐊
Stick around till the end because 😱😱 — and somehow Sweetie is the calmest one in the room. You can catch her on weekends (2-6pm) at The Florida Key Lime Pie Company, living her best gator life. Btw, their store has the largest selection of made in Fl goods I’ve ever seen! That’s a diff post tho 😉
Only in Florida. 📍 102 Dixie Lane, Cocoa Beach
👇 Would you do this?
#Cocoabeach #OnlyInFlorida #Gator Spacecoast
Fresh Key Limes are the Secret to our Delicious Real Florida Key Lime Pie!
Fun Fact: Key Limes are Yellow when Ripe not Green!
Checkout our selection of over 100 flavors of Saltwater Taffy!
Serving the only Real Florida Key Lime Pie!
Try our "Key Lime Pie on a Stick" dipped in our Key Lime Dark Chocolate!
Come and see us... we are located next to Ron Jon Surf Shop in Cocoa Beach!
